Skip to main content

Peer Feedback on Student Presentations: Use Roles for Better Feedback and Engagement

When students provide feedback to each other on presentations, do you wonder:
  1. How do I help students give each other meaningful feedback?
  2. How do I keep all students engaged during presentations and presentation feedback?
One solution to both of these challenges is assigning feedback roles.
Image result for group

Roles during practice presentations

For team presentations, I have students practice and give feedback with another team. For the team presenting, all team members stand and present as if it were the real thing. For the team giving feedback, each person focuses on a different aspect of presentation feedback. Here are roles I've used for 3-4 people teams:
  • Content - Provide feedback on the content of the presentation
  • Presentation Skills - Observe and provide feedback on presentation skills and slide design
  • Timer - Write down the times for each part of the presentation (or video tape it!)
If you provide each role feedback guidelines, like a checklist, questions, or rubric, it can help students give each other even more focused feedback.

Alternately, you could flip the roles so they apply to the feedback receivers instead of the feedback givers.  So, when the presenting team listens to feedback, each individual is responsible for improving an aspect of their presentation (content, communication, etc.) and then documents and reflects on that specific feedback. Having students process and categorize feedback is a way to promote feedback literacy.

Roles during final presentations

Now that students have practiced presenting in front of each other, their final presentations are much more polished. However, keeping students engaged with feedback helps them connect with the criteria and apply it or reflect on their own work.

A strategy I've used to encourage 100% participation during Q&A is to assign feedback roles. These roles help students consider the tone and function of their own feedback. They also ensure that presenting teams get a mix of positive and constructive comments. The roles below were adapted from EcoRise's design curriculum and can be used for team or discussion roles as well.
  • Optimist - I love the idea that..., I really liked how you...
    • Innovator - What if...? Did you consider the idea to...?
      • Analyst - How does this part work...? Can you explain more...?
        • Pessimist - This part seems infeasible because..., How will you overcome the challenge of...?
          At a table of 4, each student chooses a role to provide specific feedback or ask questions. I also give each student a post-it note for them to write down the feedback question or comment before they share with the class. Then, I ask students to turn in their post-it notes at the end of class to encourage everyone to engage in the feedback process.

          Your turn!

          If you give these strategies a shot, let us know how it goes! And share in the comments: How do you facilitate meaningful feedback on student presentations? What are your biggest successes and challenges with students giving feedback to each other?

          Comments

          Popular posts from this blog

          Part 2 - Tools for an Equitable Feedback System: Engaging with Criteria

          This series of posts will cover a variety of bite-sized strategies that can be incorporated into a more holistic feedback system. To learn more about the research behind these approaches, we recommend you first read our white paper.

          Part 1 - Feedback is Emotional



          For feedback information to be useful, it must communicate:  Where am I going? (What are the goals?)How am I going? (What progress is being made toward the goal?)Where to next? (What activities need to be undertaken to make better progress?) (Hattie & Timperley, 2007).  Supporting students in engaging with the grading criteria helps give context to the feedback to come. In other words, it does the groundwork of helping them determine for themselves, "Where am I going?"


          5-Minute Energizers to Activate You and Your Students

          We're officially in the grind. I ask my teacher colleagues how they're doing, and the standard response is a sigh: "I'm really looking forward to catching up on grading over the 3-day weekend," "I'm counting down the days until Thanksgiving," "I have 20 letters of recommendation to write."
          If we're feeling this way, our students are too! Here are super quick activities to inject energy back into your classroom: Snap, Stomp, Clap (Partners) Each person counts off to 3, i.e. Person A: "1", Person B: "2", Person A: "3", Person B: "1", etc. When everyone gets the hang of it, try it again, but replace 1's with a snap of the fingers (snap, 2, 3, snap, 2, 3, etc.) Do it again, but also replace 3's with a stomp (snap, 2, stomp, snap, 2, stomp, etc.) Do it again, but also replace 2's with a clap (snap, clap, stomp, snap, clap, stomp, etc.) Gift Giving Game (Partners) Person A pantomimes givin…

          Floop Team & Dr. Naomi Winstone: What does the research say about feedback best practices?

          Over winter break, Floop co-founder Melanie and I had the privilege of talking with prominent feedback researcher Dr. Naomi Winstone. Her research has discovered that feedback interventions all seem to target at least one of four metacognitive skills, described by the SAGE process, and hypothesizes that a holistic approach to developing feedback systems should target all four of the skills: Self-Appraisal: judging one's abilitiesAssessment Literacy: understanding the grading process, standards, and criteriaGoal-Setting & Self-Reflection: being goal-oriented and monitoring progress to meet outcomesEngagement & Motivation: having an attitude of receptiveness to performance information Essentially, for feedback to reach that level of effectiveness that we've heard from experts like Hattie & Timperly, students need to be motivated to engage with feedback and have the feedback literacy skills to use it, and the instructional environment must give them the agency to act …